Dissatisfaction with inpatient electronic health record systems among nurses has escalated to an all time high of 92 percent, according to the Q3 2014 Black Book Loyalty survey results to be published later this month. Disruption in productivity and workflow has also negatively influenced job dissatisfaction according to nurses in 84 percent of US hospitals. Eighty-five percent of nurses state they are struggling with continually flawed EHR systems and 88 percent blame financial administrators and CIOs for selecting low performance systems based on EHR pricing, government incentives and cutting corners at the expense of quality of care.
Eighty-four percent of nursing administrators in not-for-profit hospitals, and 97 percent of nursing administrators in for-profit hospitals confirm that the impact on nurses’ workloads including the efficient flow of direct patient care duties were not considered highly enough in their administration’s final EHR selection decision.
Black Book polled nearly 14,000 licensed registered nurses from forty states, all utilizing implemented hospital EHRs over the last six months. Survey respondents also ranked the vendor performance of 19 inpatient EHR systems from a nursing satisfaction perspective.
“Although the inpatient EHR replacement frenzy has calmed temporarily, the frustration from nursing EHR users has increased exponentially,” said Doug Brown, managing partner of the survey firm Black Book Market Research. “The meaningful use financial incentives for hospitals have many IT departments scurrying to implement these EHR’s without consulting direct care nurses, according to the majority of those polled by Black Book.”
- 90 percent of EHR nursing users attested that the use of the current EHR system in their facility has negatively impacted communications between nurses and their patients.
- 94 percent of nurses do not believe that the use of their current EHR has improved the communication between the nurse and the care team (physicians, respiratory therapists, physical therapists, occupational therapists, pharmacists, etc.).
- Only 26 percent agree with the statement, “As a nurse, I believe the current EHR at my organization improves the quality of patient information.”
- 51 percent of nurses working in hospitals with greater than 100 beds report that all care team members at their organization access and document on the same EHR screens.
“Technology can help nurses do their jobs more effectively or it can be a highly intrusive burden on the hospital nurse delivering patient care,” said Brown. “Many compounding nurse productivity problems of can be sourced to the failure of those selecting and implementing an EHR to involve direct care nurses in the process.”
Thirty percent of nurses believe their hospitals’ IT departments and administrations respond quickly to making changes in the EHR that the nurses recognize as vulnerabilities in documentation. Alarmingly, 69 percent of nurses in for-profit inpatient settings report their IT department as “incompetent” when describing the level of expertise their organization’s in-house staff has working with the selected EHR software.
Nurses working in for-profit, chain facilities are the most exasperated; 98 percent are dissatisfied with the time allowed to be spent with patients versus the time allowed to document on the myriad of electronic medical record and departmental programs with no connectivity that their hospitals have accumulated.
“Add to that the unique software interfaces from medical equipment and the multiple EHRs each individual physician’s office, it’s no surprise that hospital nurses are getting discouraged and seeking employment in less complex organizations,” said Brown.
“EHRs have become an advantage for some hospitals in attracting top nursing talent, but in many cases a poorly implemented EHR with chaotic processes and bungling IT support is becoming a detriment to hospital nurse retention and recruitment.”
Seventy-nine percent of job seeking registered nurses reported that the reputation of the hospital’s EHR system is a top three consideration in their choice of where they will work. Nurses in the 22 largest metropolitan statistical areas are most satisfied with the usability of Cerner, McKesson, NextGen and Epic Systems. Those EHRs receiving the lowest satisfaction scores by nurses include Meditech, Allscripts, eClinicalWorks and HCare.
A lack of IT resources is also impacting nursing productivity.
Ninety-three percent of nurses in for-profit facilities stated they do not have computers in each room or hand-held/mobile devices to aid in the EHR requirements. Ninety-one percent state they have difficulty even locating an available EHR workstation on wheels at their for-profit hospital job which, in turn, takes time away from patient care; 35 percent of nurses in not-for-profit hospitals have a similar situation of not enough devices.
Within for-profit hospital facilities, just 15 percent of the surveyed nurse respondents believed the IT department that supports the EHR are knowledgeable and receptive to nurses’ suggestions in improving electronic documentation.
Among those hospitals outsourcing the EHR help desk, 88 percent of nurses reported that their experiences with EHR’s call center do not meet their expectations of communication skills and knowledge of product. Ninety-eight percent of those directed to offshore help desks report their EHR problems being typically unresolved and that suggestions for improvement were never given consideration.
“Nurses will drive a new wave of inpatient EHR replacements and advances to outdated hybrid systems as it becomes harder to retain and recruit staff,” said Brown. “Hospitals, particularly in competitive markets, will experience an exodus of nurses who will change employers for those with flexible, highly usable EHRs, where nurses feel they can get more real time to care of patients.”
Current users ranked Cerner as the most nurse user-friendly inpatient EHR vendor, particularly in interoperability with ancillary and physician EHRs. Other vendors in the study included: Siemens, McKesson, Epic Systems, Allscripts, CPSI, GE Healthcare, NextGen, Meditech, Quadramed, HMS, HCS, RazorInsights, 3M, HCare, Vista, Healthland, Prognocis and eClinicalWorks.
Sixty-seven percent of nurses reported they have been taught workarounds to allow other health team members to view pertinent information related to a patient, as to not lower the quality of care, yet avoiding the EHR systems’ unresolved flaws.
Among the EHR vendors ranked lowest in nursing satisfaction, 89 percent of nurses report developing creative workarounds to deal with shortcomings and system deficiencies that are not addressed or corrected after reporting issues to IT and nursing supervisors.
Black Book Rankings, a division of Black Book Market Research LLC, provides healthcare decision makers, IT users, media, investors, analysts, quality minded vendors, and prospective software system buyers, pharmaceutical manufacturers, and other interested sectors of the clinical technology industry with comprehensive comparison data of the industry’s top respected and competitively performing technology and managed services vendors in the sector.